I wonder if the intimacy coordinators read Niara's critiques of the intimacy scenes and what they thought about it.
I highly doubt so.
Intimacy coordinators work at ... coordinating with the actors and actresses, the other people on set (camera, sound, motion-captors technicians, etc), and the creators, to make sure the whole process of shooting a sex scene is not too awkward, uncomfortable or worse for the actors and actresses. Intimacy coordinator are not the writers, directors or choreographers. Actually, to quote Wikipedia :
According to Intimacy Directors International, a nonprofit organization founded in 2016 by Alicia Rodis, Tonia Sina, and Siobhan Richardson that advocates for the function, an intimacy coordinator is expected to ensure that:
- all staff and actors are aware of the context of the intimacy as part of the story,
- communication about the intimacy takes place among participants and avenues for reporting harassment are available,
- actors continually consent to all scenes of intimacy,
- all scenes of intimacy are performed according to a previously agreed-to choreography, and
- actors are encouraged to mark the end of each intimate scene with a moment to signal the return to real-life interaction.
There is no reason to assume that the actors, actresses and intimaticy coordinator on BG3 had any significant input in the creative/designing process, or access to the feedback from players.
So the remaining questions are : did the sex scene writers, choreographers and directors receive Niara's feedback (or player feedback in general), or was feedback processed by system designers only ? And if the sex scene creators received the feedback, did they rework the sex scenes to make it look less like cheap porn ? We'll know soon enough.
As a side (and off-topic) note, the same sort of questions would apply to the cinematography in general. We had a player once who made a good post explaining how and why the scene of the skirmish at the Grove's Gate was very poorly shot. Again, we'll see if that sort of feedback was taken on board when we get our hands on the full release version.