I understand the plot requires a certain item, but there needs to be a dialogue option to get her to leave your camp. If the game still needs us to get the item then when we send her away she can initiate combat and we can get it that way.
Quite honestly ... i dont.
Since there is a way to keep her out of your party, the game can treat her after you send her off, exactly the same as when you simply didnt invite her in the first place ...
Also ...
I said it allready thousand times, and will repeat it thousand more ... giving cruicial plot-item to an follower was a misstake. A misstake that could have ben easily repaired, if Larian would put that box on some piedestal next to Shadowheart pod.
Player examines it > the box stick to player (just as it does when Shadowheart die)
Player save Shadowheart > she takes it and join you
Plyer ignores both > as player try to leave the room, the box fly towards them (just as it does when Shadowheart die)
Problem solved ... player have important item, Shadowheart have good reason to follow player (with their aprooval or without) ... everyone happy.
Also, i dont think she sould initiate combat ... she keeps claiming how she dont even care if we survive or not ... she should leave without a word.
Next morning we should discover her artefact in our bag ... it is working a bit like The One Ring after all.
Next night Shadowheart can appear again, demanding for us to return that box ... wich we should be able to do and repeating this scenario again next rest.
---
Lae will attack you if you don't help her with the tieflings, after which she won't be part of the party and will probably be dead. I've never tried running away from that fight though, so maybe she changes her mind at some point.
You can side with the monster hunter and kill Astarian with him and he won't come back to camp.
You can kill the grove and Halsin won't join and Wyll with leave the camp.
You can eat Gales arm and he won't join.
Apparently SH goes insane if you don't let her join as per the video above
See, FreeTheSlaves?
Posts like this makes me doubt your claim, that "all" understands the topic here, is valid...
All you mentioned benbaxter, are ways to kill our followers ...
As i stated earlier, killing is not a problem ... what i want to do, is send them away.
You know, same way as when you wish to broke up with a girl, you also dont have to kill her ... i hope.
RP wise it ultimately isn't 'Your Camp"
Yes it is, its several times stated within the game ... and every time you invite someone to your party while being full you say "go to my camp" not "go to our camp".
it is a 'Party Camp' and the others may want to keep each other around despite your wishes.
Even if ...
They would need to express themselves, wich (surprise? not really) isnt happening.
