Originally Posted by RagnarokCzD
If you really dont see any difference between:
Originally Posted by Aazo
I have killed Shadowheart on the beach

And:
Originally Posted by Darth_Trethon
Send her away enough times and she will return possessed by voices not of the tadpole or the absolute to either be accepted or to die by your hands. Refuse again and she will be driven to suicide by attacking your party.

Then we have nothing to talk about.
And if you do ... you should see the point, especialy since i spoon-fed it. :-/

---

Originally Posted by FreeTheSlaves
you can roleplay not knowing
Or not caring ...
Or knowing but valuing persons life anyway ...
Options are endless ...

Neither of them is relevant here tho, since this is not topic about "how well Shadowheart hides her secret".

This is topic about: "i find out what *XY* is ... and therefore i dont want *XY* in my party anymore ... please give me option to send them out!"

Ok?

The thing is, aside from some exeptions, you take them with you because you are in a similar bad situation. This does *not* change, just because she tells you that she is a Sharran. We may get the option *after* the tadpole situation is solved. But it makes little sense before.

The exeption would be if a companion attacks or betray the group. That does happen and you can send them away (Gale) or kill them (Astarion, Wyll, Lae'Zel).
Otherwise, not letting them turn into an Illithid is more important than to not travel with someone you do not like.