Poll results: Shadowheart vs. Karlach Halsin vs. Astarion
Battles for the ages.
Karlach I don't know about...her being or at least trying her best to be good is problematic to say the least. Now we know that at least some of the other companions can be guided towards evil so maybe there is some redemption possible for her. But her being a barbarian is also a weird fit for an evil party...we already have Minthara as a paladin and Lae'zel to serve as frontline tanks...for the third member of the party we need a healer or a caster, not another tank. Especially if the player wants to be a fighter or barbarian or some such too.
This is a bit off topic but I fear Karlach won't fit in a good aligned party. It's been speculated that her heart needs soul coins to operate. But when you use a soul coin to operate an infernal machine it tortures the soul to death and it screams entire time while its soul is being burnt away - see 4:45
Figures. If this is true then that's one less good companion from the already inadequate number of them.
