Originally Posted by kanisatha
I'm gonna have to see this contract. I need details.
Yes, all this. The answer is: it depends, because the setup doesn't account for subsequent consequences from that decision to make that pact with a devil. Saving 1,000 today but being instrumental in the suffering/deaths of millions down the road is not a good deed.[/quote]

Agreed. Which will impact the romances with either Wyll or Karlach. If I were DMing Decent to Avernus I would accept an ends-justify the means decision to use a soul coin to power an infernal machine because the lives of entire city are at stake and you even have a chance to redeem the ruler Avernus. So the destruction of one evil soul would shift your soul to evil but not condemn it.

But if Karlach is using these to keep on living? That's just evil. In 6 days we'll know if the youtubers who floated the soul coin theory are correct . . . (or probably 10 days because I don't expect to finish downloading before the weekend)

We just don't know Wyll's story now - I wanted to save him from his contract before. Will I still feel the same 🤷‍♂️?