There’s no real ambiguity about this fellows alignment an d I think even the people who think D&D alignment is outdated would agree
I mean, he's someone that will cheer and approve if you:
- rob or intimidate people - murder people - give the middle finger to anyone asking for help - cause someone misery - make fun of anyone who's suffering
But no moral judgement, please. He's just "a strong personality" or something.
Which scenes are those?
Pretty sure it's just his approval system. He tends to approve of you doing rather sadistic or callous things.
These are his actual approvals, without resorting to rhetoric like, "give the middle finger to anyone asking for help"
Are these reactions fundamentally evil?
Attack the Tieflings Ask Lae'zel to say 'please' after rescuing her Choose the 'Attack' dialogue option when speaking to Taman and Gimblebock In camp on the first night tell Shadowheart to remain cautious Ask Astarion how he wants to die, then choose an option Tell Zevlor that you have other things to do Let Arka kill Sazza (Do nothing) Tell Auntie Ethel about the tadpole Decline the devil's offer to remove the tadpole Tell him that you are not the devil's plaything Crush the tadpole that leaves True Soul Edowin Deliver the final blow to the goblin Fezzerk Let him bite you Tell him you trust him Give him Necromancy of Thay. Let him kill the Gur monster hunter, Gandrel After killing the Hag, use the wand to resurrect Mayrina's dead husband Connor, give her the wand, then tell Astarion that it was funny After asking about Cazador, tell him that you have his back as long as he has yours Deceive the goblins, say 'you can't be serious', then fling poo at them Say 'Boo' to Volo as he performs Agree to Abdirak's ritual for Loviatar Speak to the artist and call him a slave Tell the merchant Cyrel that you'll take the supplies Tell BOOOAL he is a fake god, tell him you are going to kill him and take his power
*
ETA: there was a comment about him not enjoying being a hero at the party... not enjoying being a hero doesn't equal evil.
