I chose Karlach. But it's funny that Astarion and Minthara are both the most loved and most hated characters in the community
To be fair Minthara gets a lot of votes simply because she's a required kill for one of the two initial paths in the game, at least in early access. If she could just be bypassed, or recruited regardless of path, I'm sure a lot of people would do that.
Astarion on the other hand is an either love him or hate him. A similar number of people want him dead as want to romance him.
I think he’s an obnoxious little shit, but he’s the only canon rogue so I might have to drag him along.
Remember the human (This is a forum for a video game):