That's *your* house rule, but OP is suggesting that we should be able to sneak attack with "any weapon." My original post was in response to that.
That's not my house rule, that's the house rule of another DM. I said I would be fine allowing sneak attack in connection with GWF to see how that goes. My thing about it in BG3 is that it's probably a lot of buck for very little bang.
At this point, I'm arguing for balance between the classes rather than a return to something closer to 5e RAW. And the presence of magic items that synergize with certain classes is definitely important for that.
if you're gonna base your argument on some sort of class balance thing, I don't see how rogue sneak attack needs beefing up in terms of it being too wimpy compared to other class abilities. it's a pretty strong ability as is. And letting it work with d10/d12 2-H weapons doesn't make it all that much stronger (setting aside GWF for the moment).
