Originally Posted by Zerubbabel
Are we playing the same game? The overwhelming majority of features that were promised as of a few months ago have made it into the game. While there have been demands for certain features, Larian has never indicated that they were always going to follow popular demand. The only thing that seems to have been promised and subsequently cut is the Upper City. I contend that this is not an unreasonable expectation or something fabricated by the playerbase because it did not exist in BG1 and seems to have been originally promised, and such promises are the source of demands. Are there better quest endings and epilogues in order? Yes. However, this is not an incomplete game, and some of the complaints here are issues with the entire vision Larian had for the game, rather than legitimate complaints of incompleteness.
I think a big point of contention for a lot of people are two big things they promised just two weeks before release that didn't make it into the game, the upper city of baldur's gate fully in and playable and 15 minute epilogue...now the epilogue will come...although it sounds like they're working on a different one than the datamined version, which will hopefully be better and Larian said they left it out because they were unhappy with the quality of the epilogue they had ready for the game. But the upper city it sounds like it won't. Maybe for the definitive edition but even that is probably too much to hope for. Personally I can live with it if we never get the upper city. Beyond that another major issue people had was some companions(notoriously Minthara and Karlach) were obviously missing a content, this sounds like it will be fixed in the near future with 1500 lines of reactivity for Minthara and one of Karlach's endings plus some epilogue for her set to arrive in Patch two.

Personally my take is, for me to be completely content with the game I just hope for three things: 1) all of the Minthara content, though the more the better, 2) the epilogue for all companions, and 3) albeit never promised, some of the Raven Queen content from the game files realized in the game(again, the more the better) even if later in the definitive edition.