I basically had the same reaction. Jaheira - perfection, from writing to voice acting (and the much appreciated vagueness about Gorion's Ward). Minsc - almost as well done, great fun to have around.


Sarevok - very disappointed. I can't accept this ending for him, not after starting to genuinely regard him as a sort of sibling by the end of ToB and helping him work out his redemption. Brother and sisters standing together to defy their divine father in the end - so awesome. My headcanon says this was just a shade like the other ones and I'm not budging on that.

Viconia - no opinion, I've never had her in my party, but I completely understand the disappointment. If they made a BG4 and decided to bring Astarion back as a cackling evil subvillain I would be furious.