I've been spending some time recently replaying Evil Dark Urge once more, committing to a fully solo Tactician Fighter run to see how far I can push the limits of the game, and I picked up on another small inconsistency with the story.

On your first Long Rest, when you get to talk to the Dream Visitor for the first time, he will tell you that you need to learn to control your impulses, else we will all be doomed. Ultimately, it is perfectly understandable to say that, but here's the thing: this interaction comes off as the Visitor reading Tav's body language moreso than what he is actually doing, which is peering into your mind as the Emperor. However, he doesn't comment on the Urge ever again afterwards. You could assume that it is because he would keep quiet about your horrible deeds, playing along until he can dispose of you atop the Netherbrain, but of course this isn't something that happens, so it is just fanfic (my fanfic) at best.

On another note, it is just strange that it is implied that the Urge isn't held by the thoughts of fantasizing about chopping the Visitor's hand off. Now, either Tav is completely unhinged or fighting hard against the Urge depending on your playthrough, but when you play into being a monster, it is strange to imply that unless Sceleritas is there to manipulate you from a distance (and that by proxy, he can't follow you into the Astral Prism), committing brutal deeds is just simply a passing thought, a thought that anyone could have in the heat of the moment, but choose to dismiss and not act on it. It's also worth to note that when you get to talk to Sceleritas later, you have the option to tell him that the Urge itself doesn't matter as you love killing anyways. There isn't a throughline here at all, especially considering that when it comes to Gale's hand, that fantasy very much transformed into reality yet with the Visitor it just simply not a thing because plot armor, but it does confirm that Sceleritas (or rather Bhaal, but this is of course something you won't know till Act3) is the source of the Urge.