In my first playthrough,
Orin kidnapped Gale and Jenna went missing and never came back.

Second time around,
I really wanted to save Jenna and the cat. So I brought Gale and Halsin with me at all times, leaving Lae'zel behind. Then I got the scene where "Lae'zel" claimed Jenna was the imposter and tried killing her, but I rolled a persuasion roll or something like that that made "Lae'zel" reveal herself to be Orin saying that the real Lae'zel had been taken. Then Orin left, leaving Jenna and the cat in camp. This way I had both Jenna and the cat with me and then had to rescue Lae'zel.

I did try different routes here, but every other companion (Halsin, Gale) being taken resulted in Jenna going missing. Might be a bug though. And if I kept all three in my group, Jenna was taken and the cat died.

Last edited by EMar; 15/09/23 08:51 AM.