Originally Posted by Aulis Vaara
There were probably a handful of good points, but honestly gents, if you can do better: please go do so.
Ah, that tired way of dismissing any discussion without having to engage with it. "Ah, I think car I bought is having issues? Whaaat? Can you build a better one?"

Which part of my commend you didn't like? That I liked D:OS1 the best? Or that I said it's plot was incoherent?

The latter isn't even meant as a criticism, nor is a controvertial statement. Sven himself openly admitted that in D:OS1 story was an afterthought - and that's something they have been striving to improve ever since. And succesfully - each release they did was stronger narrative-wise, even though I still there is a fundamental conflict between Larian's idea of fun gameplay and narratives they try to tell. Still, the story has issues. And personally, I will take a game with little focus on story that is 100% fun, than a game with large focus of troubled story that mires my experience.