I mean i kinda agree from both sides. The game has so much going for it. Like god damn larian did an amazing job on 95% of this game. But that sadly just makes that 5% of missing content/ story issues/ ending issues all the more glaring because of it imo its like having a 4 course meal where the first 3 courses are fantastic etc etc...but half way through desert it just starts to taste sour and bitter. You leave remembering the sour and bitter. Everything else is overshadowed by it really
So does it deserve the praise its gotten? 100% and larian deserves the credit due for what they have worked on.
But they also deserve the critizism for that last 5%. We should just be respectful about it. While voicing concerns and calls for them to address it. Far more likely we will get what were hoping for that way id wager.