Yeah, WotR is the by far better game. The only thing BG3 has is visuals, the name, and unhealthy simping for "mommy Karlach" and "Bear Sex Halsin".
Sadly sex sells for the masses and BG3 is the more successful game. Reality is rarely fair.

And you are right, replayability is much better in WotR. Each path adds a lot more content than a origin and the game does feel different despite most of it being the same. Meanwhile Larian cant even manage to make an evil path.