Originally Posted by kanisatha
Originally Posted by Warlocke
Originally Posted by snowram
Just by reading the title, my eyes rolled up inside my skull. How can a critically acclaimed game, both by the public and the critics, be bad for a genre?

The answer to your question is: Tedious gatekeeping.
Oh right. Of course! BG3 cheerleading is legit. But BG3 criticism is gatekeeping.

Well let me proudly engage in some "gatekeeping" by declaring that all claims to BG3 being a cRPG are bullshit. BG3 is the worst form of AAA game, a game carried entirely by cinematics and sex and a big fat zero on everything that makes an RPG meaningful.

Then why are you wasting your precious time to talk about it? Seriously, I don't want to spark another argument, but this is beyond me. And you haven't even played the damn game. The fact it's the worst AAA game is profoundly misleading. It may be the worst AAA game to *you*, but not to millions of others. I passionately hate From Software games, seriously, even more that you hate BG3, but I would never dare to call any of their games the worst game of all. I simply don't like this art and narrative style.