Originally Posted by Seho
Nothing happens in Act 1 and 2, so he says it from the beginning, before the romance.
SH and Astarion are ok with that, because Halsin doesn't want any commitment, the other companions want one.
He is like that and he can be like that.
Have you even played the game? Over half of his dialogue is flirting during the party. He gets a fair amount of dialogue during those acts as well, where you can ask about his past and hint toward a future together.

Astarion will break up with you for way less. Shadowheart will break up with you if you do anything with the other companions in act 2 and that's when she's way less vulnerable (pre-Nightsong). In Wyll's case it's literally just a kiss. At no point, at all, do you get to tell her it's non-committal. Neither with the origin companions, or with Halsin. In fact, in Shadowheart's case, you get the Halsin romance scene before you even get hers. She's not okay with the drow twins - literal prostitutes, you can't get more non-committal than that - before you had hers, but she's okay with Halsin? Again, forced retcon for the sake of Halsin's romance plot.

Last edited by Michieltjuhh; 30/09/23 01:14 PM.