Larian Banner: Baldur's Gate Patch 9
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 4 of 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 23 24
Joined: Sep 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Veranis
Originally Posted by vx_phoenix_vx
FYI, based off what you said, I went all the way back just to get this. Had to redo the fight.

Holy crap. Worth it. That was the sweetest damn moment ever. Probably my favorite save maybe the graveyard scene. Like...

It's got the bad ending taste out of my mouth.

The "Oh shit. What...what did I do wrong?" Agh! For a second I was like "Veranis, I better not regret this or I'm blaming you!!"

It's great, isn't it? laugh I'm glad you liked it, too. I was feeling so bad reading that you did not have a good time with the DUrge ending. This scene is one of the reasons why redeemed DUrge and spawn Astarion are my preferred combo. It shows how commited to each other both of them have become. They redeem each other.

I just wish this kind of writing would have poured over to the ending. As it is now it feels like the relationship is back to square one (maybe two), all that development is wiped away.

Well, I very luckily had the scene where your Urge
tries to kill him in Act 2
so I didn't have to redo too much cause like I said, I was going full evil.

Going full evil still has a super awful ending but I blame that on the endings for the game in general at this point.

Now I need to figure out if it's worth it to go back again just to get Ascendant ending dialogue....
I might be working too hard for breadcrumbs, I just love this game so much! And to see it have all the potential in the world and fall flat in such an unsatisfying way is heartbreaking...


#JusticeForAstarion
Joined: Sep 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by SheWildWolf
Originally Posted by andromeda087
Durge is the BEST character to romance Astarion, in my opinion. I'm assuming that they have these little interactions because they share the same writer (Stephen Rooney). It is wonderfully written.

But you're right spawn/DU relationship is so sweet. It seems that Astarion found someone who is even more broken than himself. Someone who [I quote] "gives him something to care for". It is nice to see that soft and caring side of Astarion under all that luster of his pretend persona.

After doing DUrge and romancing Astarion, I see no point in playing plain Tav. You get so much more depth in his romance with DU. I wish I didn't waste all that time on 3 playthrough playing Tav...

If they would just fix the ending now, that will be great. But I think the ending is bad in general.

This post gives me hope. I keep seeing how awful the Astarion romance endings are and it makes me not want to finish the game, just reroll a new character. Honestly, this makes me want to reroll as DU now though.

Also, regarding them giving us a new ending for Astarion like they did for Karlach, how much fuss would we have to kick up to get it to happen? Online petitions? Spamming social media? Bogging down the forums with posts and requests about it? I say we start a movement!


I hope they pay attention to this thread! It doesn't have near as much attention as the Karlach thread but Astarion's "good" ending is mentioned everywhere in the forums talking about endings. There's also another semi-popular thread talking about its tone-deafness.

I've been running around trying to boost any thread that talks about Astarion's ending because of it lol


#JusticeForAstarion
Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Yeah, now his "bad" path is better for him (and the player) than the "good" path, both gameplay and epilogue wise.

I'm personally fine with him staying a vampire. His problem was always with Cazador, not vampirism, and he seems to appreciate the possibility of a very long life. Man survived 200 years of Cazador and a near end of the world, he'll be fine chilling in Baldur's Gate. Especially when he's known as part of the group of people who saved the city and the Gur monster hunters promised to leave him alone.

But that absolute atrocity of his ending scene, that needs to go. I don't remember any other game I played that would have given a more tone deaf ending to a character.

Joined: Sep 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Yeah, now his "bad" path is better for him (and the player) than the "good" path, both gameplay and epilogue wise.

I'm personally fine with him staying a vampire. His problem was always with Cazador, not vampirism, and he seems to appreciate the possibility of a very long life. Man survived 200 years of Cazador and a near end of the world, he'll be fine chilling in Baldur's Gate. Especially when he's known as part of the group of people who saved the city and the Gur monster hunters promised to leave him alone.

But that absolute atrocity of his ending scene, that needs to go. I don't remember any other game I played that would have given a more tone deaf ending to a character.

Agreed with this. Though, I wouldn't mind a DLC or expansion exploring the possibility of curing him.

But I care much more about them expanding dialogue in Act 3 and getting rid of the ending scene that turns his journey into a punchline.

I don't think he needs a perfectly happy ending, just one that gives him respect akin to his development. The man is so much more than a vampire fuckboy. And whoever wrote his ending seems to not know that.


#JusticeForAstarion
Joined: Sep 2023
V
member
Offline
member
V
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by vx_phoenix_vx
Well, I very luckily had the scene where your Urge
tries to kill him in Act 2
so I didn't have to redo too much cause like I said, I was going full evil.

Going full evil still has a super awful ending but I blame that on the endings for the game in general at this point.

Now I need to figure out if it's worth it to go back again just to get Ascendant ending dialogue....
I might be working too hard for breadcrumbs, I just love this game so much! And to see it have all the potential in the world and fall flat in such an unsatisfying way is heartbreaking...

I guess it depends how far back you have to go to get to
the Orin fight to be able to defy Bhaal and get rid of his influence. I usuually do that right before Ghortash and then off to the brain.
It's still a bit, but not that bad. I don't even want to admit how much I have been playing for breadcrumbs lately just to see every kind of variation to certain scenes. *cough* But playing one playthrough with just Astarion as only origin companion was hella fun.

Originally Posted by vx_phoenix_vx
But I care much more about them expanding dialogue in Act 3 and getting rid of the ending scene that turns his journey into a punchline.

I don't think he needs a perfectly happy ending, just one that gives him respect akin to his development. The man is so much more than a vampire fuckboy. And whoever wrote his ending seems to not know that.

I feel the same. I like his ending. It's hopeful and since we all know that cures for vampirism exist, it's just a matter of time until he and Tav find one. They are freaking lvl 12 heroes. laugh I don't need to see it ingame. But I do want a respectful ending for him. And an expanded end-dialogue that makes sense for two people in love.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
You know, the game conditioned me so well with lack of companion reactivity in Act 3 and his garbage ending that I saw that dialog and was happy. And then I never saw it again because I didn't want to go through that ending again. All my playthroughs now end after we deal with Cazador and Orin. But thinking back on it, yes, it doesn't look like an epilogue with a romanced character at all.

Joined: Nov 2020
Location: Silverymoon
old hand
Offline
old hand
Joined: Nov 2020
Location: Silverymoon
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
All my playthroughs now end after we deal with Cazador and Orin.

That's where a good number of my playthroughs end too. Avoids so many problems!

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Tarlonniel
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
All my playthroughs now end after we deal with Cazador and Orin.

That's where a good number of my playthroughs end too. Avoids so many problems!

Sometimes I take SH to finish her quest. Have a chat with Gortash if I'm Durge. The rest just feels like a chore, especially the last fights when you know what kind of ending awaits you.

Joined: Aug 2020
enthusiast
Offline
enthusiast
Joined: Aug 2020
Originally Posted by SheWildWolf
Also, regarding them giving us a new ending for Astarion like they did for Karlach, how much fuss would we have to kick up to get it to happen? Online petitions? Spamming social media? Bogging down the forums with posts and requests about it? I say we start a movement!

I am betting a lot of fuss, look at how many pages Karlach's demand for better endings has lol.

Sure, whenever bad endings are being mentioned people always tend to bring Astarion up... and rightfully so. Ascended Astarion's ending is fine, but spawn Astarion is just beyond bad.

Also add to that the forbidden word: datamining. Everyone knows at this point that the Upper City was supposed to be explorable outside of the last hour or two of the game, but was shafted due to time constraints. Karlach's proper idea for permanently fixing her engine laid there and apparently some sort of an idea for a cure for vampirism laid there too. Y'know, Hall of Wonders and that temple district... so many possibilities.

Joined: Sep 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Originally Posted by Tarlonniel
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
All my playthroughs now end after we deal with Cazador and Orin.

That's where a good number of my playthroughs end too. Avoids so many problems!

Sometimes I take SH to finish her quest. Have a chat with Gortash if I'm Durge. The rest just feels like a chore, especially the last fights when you know what kind of ending awaits you.

Yeah, in my case, my first playthrough was a completionist round. I even found all the clown parts.

But my second playthrough, I blitzed everything. Explored a few quests I didn't get last time.

Next time I play, I'll do even less.


#JusticeForAstarion
Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Nicottia
Originally Posted by SheWildWolf
Also, regarding them giving us a new ending for Astarion like they did for Karlach, how much fuss would we have to kick up to get it to happen? Online petitions? Spamming social media? Bogging down the forums with posts and requests about it? I say we start a movement!

I am betting a lot of fuss, look at how many pages Karlach's demand for better endings has lol.

Sure, whenever bad endings are being mentioned people always tend to bring Astarion up... and rightfully so. Ascended Astarion's ending is fine, but spawn Astarion is just beyond bad.

Also add to that the forbidden word: datamining. Everyone knows at this point that the Upper City was supposed to be explorable outside of the last hour or two of the game, but was shafted due to time constraints. Karlach's proper idea for permanently fixing her engine laid there and apparently some sort of an idea for a cure for vampirism laid there too. Y'know, Hall of Wonders and that temple district... so many possibilities.

I wonder what Astarion's main writer thinks about that ending scene. I don't believe he's the one who wrote that shit.

Literally all they have to do is give the man some shade to stand in instead of running and it's immediately better.

Joined: Nov 2021
A
member
Offline
member
A
Joined: Nov 2021
I sure hope that he didn't write it. It certainly doesn't fit with the way the rest of Astarion's story was written.

I really don't know what in the world people at Larian were thinking with that dock scene. Who thought that it would be a good idea to give such an awful ending to the people who were invested in Astarion? Really? Such a tasteless joke...

Joined: Nov 2020
Location: Silverymoon
old hand
Offline
old hand
Joined: Nov 2020
Location: Silverymoon
There's a bit of a pattern in Act III with the companions becoming less "people" and more "video game characters" - collections of pixels we're not really supposed to get attached to or take seriously. Possibly just another symptom of Larian running out of time to polish things.

Joined: Aug 2020
enthusiast
Offline
enthusiast
Joined: Aug 2020
Originally Posted by Tarlonniel
There's a bit of a pattern in Act III with the companions becoming less "people" and more "video game characters" - collections of pixels we're not really supposed to get attached to or take seriously. Possibly just another symptom of Larian running out of time to polish things.

Couldn't have put it better myself. Honestly, entire act 3 is just a mess. The only thing that is polished in act 3 is House of Hope.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Nicottia
Originally Posted by Tarlonniel
There's a bit of a pattern in Act III with the companions becoming less "people" and more "video game characters" - collections of pixels we're not really supposed to get attached to or take seriously. Possibly just another symptom of Larian running out of time to polish things.

Couldn't have put it better myself. Honestly, entire act 3 is just a mess. The only thing that is polished in act 3 is House of Hope.

Halsin turns into an atrocity, we get an obligatory brothel orgy scene (using companions with backstories least suited for it), Mizora is forced on you and does nothing apart from standing there propositioning you for sex, your companions don't care whatever you do with Haarlep, and the game ends with an abuse victim running away in pain while the rest of the party make fun of him.

Joined: Oct 2023
E
stranger
Offline
stranger
E
Joined: Oct 2023
The tonal whiplash of Gale expressing genuine sympathy for Astarion during and after Astarion’s personal quest and then laughing at him on the docks was really something else.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by EldritchBlast
The tonal whiplash of Gale expressing genuine sympathy for Astarion during and after Astarion’s personal quest and then laughing at him on the docks was really something else.

This is why Gale stays in Durge's bag.

Joined: Sep 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Originally Posted by Nicottia
Originally Posted by Tarlonniel
There's a bit of a pattern in Act III with the companions becoming less "people" and more "video game characters" - collections of pixels we're not really supposed to get attached to or take seriously. Possibly just another symptom of Larian running out of time to polish things.

Couldn't have put it better myself. Honestly, entire act 3 is just a mess. The only thing that is polished in act 3 is House of Hope.

Halsin turns into an atrocity, we get an obligatory brothel orgy scene (using companions with backstories least suited for it), Mizora is forced on you and does nothing apart from standing there propositioning you for sex, your companions don't care whatever you do with Haarlep, and the game ends with an abuse victim running away in pain while the rest of the party make fun of him.

Don't get me started on how pointless Mizora is. I can't even get her to leave! Once I'd exhausted all of her conversation options, I asked her to leave cause at that point, she's there to ask you for sex and then just...exist in that space. She doesn't even become an ally for the ending so she's literally there for no other reason.

But getting back to the point of the thread, Astarion's ending points to a larger issue with the whole of Act 3. Like a lot of people have said, the tone is entirely different from quest to quest.

Astarion's companion quests was one of the most unique experiences I've had in a game. Never have I felt such genuine interest and concern for a video game character.

Couple that with like...hunting down the murderer in Lower City or getting the stupid mail for the post office? Like...the quests are not the same. And the mail and murderer quest last a lot longer than Astarion's quest with very little substance.

It speaks to Act 3 just being where everyone's leftover ideas drained to. They needed a lot to happen so any weird idea that was shouted out was crammed into it to make the Act longer. Definitely done by a different set of writers than the people doing the companion stories.

And Astarion's god-awful dock scene capitalizes on and confirms this.

Last edited by vx_phoenix_vx; 07/10/23 10:31 AM.

#JusticeForAstarion
Joined: Aug 2023
I
journeyman
Offline
journeyman
I
Joined: Aug 2023
Correct me if I am wrong because I didn't romance Astarion in my playthrough.

I read some where that Astarion will remain as a vampire in the end but Tav who romanced him stays by his side in one of the so called "good" ending? I think this is a pretty decent ending?

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by iloverainbow
Correct me if I am wrong because I didn't romance Astarion in my playthrough.

I read some where that Astarion will remain as a vampire in the end but Tav who romanced him stays by his side in one of the so called "good" ending? I think this is a pretty decent ending?

The problem is not him staying a vampire and doesn't even have to do anything with romancing him. The problem is the scene on the docks. After all he's gone through, and just started recovering, he runs away in pain while some other companion makes a dumb comment. And you can't even go after him.

Page 4 of 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 23 24

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5