Originally Posted by Zentu
I understand the out pouring for options but personally do not see the Karlach ending as all that bad. You have essentially three options.

1) She stays with you in Baldurs Gate and dies.

2) She goes back to Avernus, with you and Wyll, with just you or just Wyll.

3) She becomes a Mind Flayer and is thus saved from having to go to Avernus.

While you might hope for another option, these are actually pretty solid from a lore/story point of view. I appreciate others want a different ending but there is a point to where it just gets untenable. I mean how many different endings should they create? There is no way to please everyone so you do what you can and that is all you can do.


Yeah buddy you might wanna swap accounts if you wanna participate in this "hot" discussion here with that take of yours, its never nice seeing people with certain powers state their opinion that goes against almost everyone elses here in this thread.
Not only is your take super bad and lowkey one dimensional, but also now we have to be afraid you just straight up delete comments or ban anyone that takes a stance against your bad opinion.

The only essence Im getting from your comment is: " (almost) Everyone else in this games has a happy ending, so why should Karlach get one? She already has one!" Yeah buddy, sending her back to the place where she got abused and taken advantage of for almost her enitre life - damn what a good ending ! (Incoming but you are going with her and you can fight against Zariel!) Yeah no, how about take some DND lessons, even a group of 4x Level 12 with preperations wouldnt just casually wipe Zariel - going with 2 or (if you include Wyll) 3? Yeah hf getting killed or enslaved as well.

Also "
She becomes a Mind Flayer and is thus saved from having to go to Avernus.
Did you even pay attention to the game? Withers literally tells you that Mindflayers
have no Soul and ONLY a few can stay the way they were before, the 3 we know of are Emperor, Omeluum and Orpheus, the rest of the infected people will turn into Soulless Mindflayers faking/pretending to be the person they ate the brain of because they took on their memories, this will slowly fade away over time until they become the usual monster known as Mindflayer
and to think Karlach also belongs amongst them 3 is pretty high on copium, even more copium than all of us hoping for an actual good ending

So please, if you wanna continue making a fool of yourself, at least switch to a non Mod account so I dont have to be afraid getting banned by you when I disprove all your points

Last edited by Drakaah; 04/10/23 05:51 PM.