Originally Posted by Bigli
Originally Posted by Michieltjuhh
Yet completely fitting.

Throughout the game it's been hinted at that relationships and anything casual is actually looked down upon by Shar because it means you're not doing her bidding. They needed to find excuses or do it secretly. The only time this narrative is flipped upside down is when you cheat on Mizora, where the writing is inconsistent with the rest of the dialogue in the game.

This is why she doesn't do jack in act 1 and act 2. She knows Shar wouldn't approve. But she herself wants it, that's why she's conflicted between choosing you and Shar, and unhappy when you do anything with another companion.

Then you get the Nightsong choice. In act 3, you have Sharran or Selunite Shadowheart.

Both want you for themselves, so neither should want to share you whatsoever; not with Halsin, not with the drows and not with Mizora. The only difference is that the Sharran version needs to find an excuse to get down with you because she doesn't want to piss off Shar (hence she calls it an exception), whereas the Selunite version will devote her everything to you (move in together, start a family) because that's what she personally wanted all along and now Shar's not there to stop her.

The only thing that strays from his own writing here is Halsin, the drows and Mizora. Three completely avoidable and short dialogues.
Hmmm, I've never done her Shar route so I've been ignorantly saying that this sharing thing should be Shar route exclusive but after reading this you're right her willingness to share makes literally no sense regardless of what route you go with her. The whole thing SHOULD be removed but I'm sure even if a definitive edition happens they'll still keep it for inclusiveness.
Or they just could fix Halsin situation because it's out of player's agency. So both poly and mono players will be happy. Literally nothing changes for those who want to do double romance, but those who want only Shadowheart wont get this stupid banter and drow conversation. Mizora still can be interpreted as "acceptance", remember that even in her endings she says that she will be easy to find if Tav changes their mind and she is ALWAYS soft with your Tav, so thats ok.