Yep but using that great sword with 18 Str will give you 10-22 damage; a crit with it is +2d6 damage (2-12) for a total of 12-34 damage, which is quite a ways off from 83 damage per swing you see. If all the rest of your gear is focused on improving your crit rate, it’s rather hard for it to also add +50 damage per swing. Even if we assume you’re using an elixir to improve your Str to 27 and Great Weapon Master, that’s +18 damage, leaving you 32 damage per swing short even if you rolled max damage. So it does indeed matter what other gear she used, as your claims as presented are simply not possible.
Edit: note those damage ranges; a crit at this point is doing up to 12 higher than a non-crit. You said 4 of them were crits but now you’re saying 500 damage divided by 6 is 83.33 as though someone didn’t already know that. Are you trying to claim all 6 attacks did exactly 84 damage, crit and non-crit alike? That certainly seems…. Unlikely at best.
Last edited by GiantOctopodes; 09/10/23 12:45 PM.
