Originally Posted by Netav
I mean I really like his writting on Shadowheart overall(aside from obvious).

And that's totally fine. I can't say the dude has no skill/talent when it comes to writing (he did manage to write some enjoyable parts of the story) but if you are paying attention you'll notice that all 3 companions that he has written have the same (how should I put this in diplomatic terms lol) 'issue' popping up. And I'm willing to put money on the table that his next one is going to have the same problem.

Originally Posted by Cowoline
Look, you can complain about Quinn all you want, but again he was also consistent in his writing. And Quinn at least has a redemption arch. Halsin is just an inconsistent mess.

Oh no doubt about it. Quin has his redemption arc and is consistent (being a weasel that he is). What I meant was more in a way that he is a good candidate for being a hated companion/npc and not how he was written.