Thanks for the list and input!
The only one I personally strongly disagree with is Savage Attacker, it gets proportionally worse the more dice you have and I can promise you it’ll never be more than +3 average damage on those smites. Compared to something like Sentinel which grants additional capabilities and attacks it’ll just never give you the same kind of impact. If someone likes it more power to them, but since all it does is increase damage, and it’s not a huge damage increase at that, I’d never put it in the “must have” category for any class, but especially Paladin given they’re MAD and love ASIs and also melee tanks who can benefit from half a dozen feats more than they could Savage Attacker.
Just Mho of course but if you’re curious about the math I’d be glad to share it out.
