Originally Posted by Cowoline
Thank you so much!

And yes, I have been mocked for this, but the way poly (and I use the term lightly) works right now, there is no option for people only attracted to women.

Why the Hell isn't it possible to have Karlach and Shadowheart? Move the poly conversation from act 2 to act 3 and don't just make it about Halsin, and then run the romances as normal.
The way it is right now(And there is too much evidence for this, you can check it in SH thread) SH acts as mono character, she denies any proposal about poly and wants Tav all for herself.
Tav/Karlach/SH for example(remember that SH flirts with Karlach and finds her attractive at least)
Shadowheart: I can't help but notice you seem happier of late. There's a spring in your step that wasn't there before. Just a pity I'm not responsible for it.
Tav: I'm not a swan - I don't mate for life. I want to be with you and Karlach.
Shadowheart: I admire your ambition - and your belief in your own stamina - but Karlach deserves you to herself. And perhaps there's someone out there for me...
Shadowheart: There's no hard feelings - genuinely. You deserve happiness, and I'm more than glad to remain with you to bear witness to it.
If Tav choses SH over Karlach:
Shadowheart: I can't help but notice you seem happier of late. There's a spring in your step that wasn't there before. Just a pity I'm not responsible for it.
Tav: I didn't realise you felt that way about me.
Shadowheart: Sometimes it can be difficult to know what you want - what you need - until it's already lost to you. I know that from experience.
Shadowheart: I won't lie. I won't pretend that part of me isn't hoping you'll look in my eye and still feel something.
Shadowheart: Foolish, I know. But allow me to wallow in the fantasy a moment, bittersweet as it is.
Tav: Wait. This is wrong. You're the one I'm supposed to be with. I see that now.
Shadowheart: But what about Karlach? You'd break her heart just to be with me?
Tav: Consider it done.
Shadowheart: I won't lie... I feel a little sorry for her. But only a little bit.
Shadowheart: You may be what's been missing from my life.
So its almost like SH sees Halsin as just a source of "casual sex" without relationship. I have no other explanation for this given her behaviour throughout the game tbh.

Last edited by Netav; 12/10/23 05:19 PM.