So i have playthrough at Tav bard which helped tieflings and harpers and i was at Act 3, and at the same time i have evil playthrough by dark urge then i have some troubles with my PC and after reinstallation my saves dissapeared. At the same time i did an evil walkthrough by Urge and the personality of that character is much more interesting than custom Tav (despite my Durge wasn't white dragonborn storm sorcerer), so i would like to have again walkthrough but now i can't decide which of path will be more interesting and enjoyable, and have some questions:
1. Did Wyll & Karlach personal quests really worth to chose good-alignment walkthrough? Because i rarely taked them in my first walkthrough. Wyll was only on fight with Ketheric because I would like to got infernal rapier from Mizora and Karlach was only when i did part of her personal quest in Act 1 by defeating fake paladins. They both not interesting to me, Laezel also much better melee warrior than Karlach and Gale is better spellcaster.
2. Same question to Jaheira quest, in 3 Act i only finished the quest where she find out that Stone Lord is Minsc, is there any point for this take her with you?
3. How much Minthara is better as companion than Karlach and Wyll?
4. What loot except Dammon's armor i will lost if i will raid the Grove?
5. Is that possible to be semi-evil in Dark Urge walkthrough? For example, Save the tieflings but kill Nightsong and make Shadowheart Dark Justiciar, or resist urges all times and become in 3 act unholy assasin? (for the last i only want bhaalist armor on my hero)?