Why is your interpretation more accurate than mine?
It isn't. Both are equally valid because both are a result of an individual's own thoughts on the matter. But a few people continue being vocal about how they want interactions that support a non-monogamous interpretation removed wholesale, while the people who interpret it that way are kinda just here to be like no reading it the other way is fine and valid please don't simply remove it entirely, it'd be cooler to improve on it.
Originally Posted by Ehhhh123
in terms of popularity here speaks for itself.
The thread is so active because of the constant argument caused by the premise, not necessarily the premise itself. We all got invested in one aspect of the character/romance or another and are arguing from a place of that enjoyment. And the one point we (mostly) all agree on is what you just emphasized: the problems with Halsin.