Halsin has one good thing going on for him: if he gets abducted by you know who, then everybody survives, unlike when the three other options get abducted. Found this out yesterday and was happy, that both, the girl and the cat, were happy and healthy. And Scratch too - the abduction scene for Halsin is quite dramatic in that regard, but don't worry, our bestest boi is fine. Plus, the Halsin fans can get him back unscathed and the people, who don't want him in camp can just 'botch' the persuasion role later. I think, that will be my go to solution in good playthroughs from now on.

"We are all stories in the end. Just make it a good one."

Doctor Who