I can't really tell if Dynia is a troll, but he's got a point prioritising accuracy over damage (up to a point), due to the limited health of the mobs. An extreme example to illustrate, 100% hitroll for 10 damage would be better in BG3 than 1% hitroll for 2,000 damage even if the latter has a higher expected damage over time. This is even more important since damage affects concentration, so misses may leave your party incapacitated for longer.
Yeah, that point has never been denied. It's just that up to a certain hit chance, enhancing raw damage by using GWM or sharpshooter is a real bonus, that's what has been argued and opposed from him without any maths to back it up.
