Well maybe im Wrong but for Me Astarion should Never Had a Good ending.. he is a Thief and a Vampire.. theres no GOOD in him.. i all my games when i was playing a good dude by the time i get to finish his quest when i refuse to help him becouse i will not create another moster im a hero.. he just made me kill him.. i Beleave that He never was supposed to be played as a Good Guy like a Said.. he is a Vampire and a Thief.. dude in Any tabletop he at least would have been a Neutral evil..meaning he was never supposed to be GOOD. But ho knows maybe im Wrong and yu guys are corret.. i just always felt that he is a Companion Perfect for a Durge game or a Evil one becouse in all my evil games he basicly become my right arm man and minthara my Demonic Godess. RS and Fun Fact He was like a Devil in my shoulder the entire game like in old Cartoons.. haha