Whats the point of making a deal with rapheal when you can raid the house of hope?
Whats the point of continuing wylls contract when you can still save his father?
Dude i get you like the depressong stuff and the idea* of making the *hard choice* and in bg3 you have the OPTION* to pursue it in alot of areas.
But no it doesnt dimmish the narrative. To implement the fixed engine ending which was clearly intended baded on stuff alrdy in the game. No ones going to take away your tragedy.
Your good.
For the rest of us we are just spitballing ideas and concerns and hoping Larian takes note.