Very politely, if a bit tiredly: Can't you just. See that we will never agree on what makes a good narrative here and how that narrative interacts with context? Like we got your point, and you clearly aren't open to changing your view either, do you really expect us to see the error of our ways and stop talking? What's the end goal of the debate here, genuinely? I'm always down for a good discussion of different views, but by now it's obvious there's no common ground to be found here. Especially if the gameplay standpoint is a non-argument for you, and that's like at least 50% of what we're talking about, if not more.
We aren't hurting anyone by sitting in a separate thread and "whining" about our questionable tastes in tragedies and dreams for an equal content amount.
And if you're afraid that Larian will actually change something because of us (which, again, they won't if they don't deem it a reasonable addition) and somehow that would ruin your whole enjoyment of the game, then I'm afraid whatever damage we could do we have already done.