Originally Posted by Noelle666
Originally Posted by AmayaTenjo
Its kind of sad that thats a legit way to atempt a happy ending with Halsin
Unfortunately, not only with him. Feels like, there is no "happily ever after" for all (or almost all) companions. That's why we have threads for Karlack, Astarion, Halsin, Shadowheart and more.
People mostly want to have a possibility to get a happy ending for everything and everyone. And what we have in BG3 seems, on one hand, wrong. I mean, yes, we were connected with our companions mostly because of tadpoles and we needed to get rid of this problem, but still even after what we've been through it would be nice to have something good in the end. (I am still in Act 3 of my first playthrough, need to finish several quests, but I read some spoilers about some companions, so the picture looks kind of gloomy).
Well, you get "happy ending" with SH in 3 out of 4 choices.
You don't get happy ending if you let her execute parents as dark justicar. DJ + saved parents = happy ending, Selunite + saved parents = happy ending, Selunite + released parents = happy ending. Also applies to being squid. I think there is an option to stay with her as a squid in 4 of 4 of her endings actually(but thats very selfish imo)
It's matter of preference what ppl think is more right to chose.
The problem with SH is not ending, but other things in game, which were voiced many times before and I don't want to get to it again in Halsin thread(even though the problems are mostly with SH/Halsin ingame interactions).