Well i already Say That i do Beleave that Karlach situation and AStarion in the Good ending are the Worst..
totally wrong what happens to then.. even so that i dont care or never romance then i feell your pain my dude im not joking..
( i already have some similar situation in another games 1 of then even came from Larian for the old fans they may understand the character im talking about..)
but the fact is Its Not Just Her that get a Shitty ending.. like the dude says in the end yu get 3 options in the good route..
a Party, Rebuild the City or Just Leave..
Looks like we are just able to leave and have sex with romance option and they say just a few lines and thats it..
like Oona Says..
This game just need Something.. a Simple Stupid Party so we can talk to then 1 last time then we get to F. our romance and Credits with some stupid Slides.. that i would be ok and tolarate as ending..
but thats not the case.
they just Cut your balls off in the end left yu asking what the hell is happening here and thats it.. Withers and Raphael if yu chose the worst decision in the game Great move on now please ?
thats what i get for good ending..huahauhauhauha
(i already told that but yu know why in the 9 hells i beat this game so many times ? becouse i really felt that the ending i get was my foult.. becouse i felt i really miss or forget to save someone to change that shit.. and hit even harder after 900 hrs and yu realize that is just that indeed.)
yu have 2 options of turn in to squid to save the day or go with the squid to save the day HUrray GREAT STORY Telling. lol
even in Dragon Age inquistion wich is a Far inferior game then this game in act1,2 i get a Decent Ending.. even better if yu buy the expancion Man the ending with solas even if yu dont Romance him its Brutal..
the dude just take of my power and my arm and i was left in my knees like i was some dog shit in front of a Demi God Shit that Hurt but was amazing.
like see stupid human i was the snake the entire time and yu just beleaved in me.
(and till this day i want to slay that asshole really hard.)
another Great Example
The ending with blood and wine with Regis.. Shit if yu never saw just play that shit man.. yu will want to put down the game in the end thats a True Eding.. that shit actually make me cry like a baby
like i was sending finally a proper ending for the Greatest Hero That ever lived and Geralt really need that especially if yu read the books yu will understand me.
i can give yu Many, Many, Many More exemples of a Great Ending. and i do love some dark and Cruel ending.. i do but here its the only one worth something.. and thats so Sad.