Originally Posted by Noelle666
Originally Posted by papercut_ninja
In this case, I think it needed a lot more polish and more baking time, but that's my personal opinion, other people think it's great.
I agree, it needs much more time, attention and maybe even carefulness to make good representation.

Originally Posted by Asri
It does seem odd to me after his characterization in Act 1 and 2. IMO, it seems like Shadowheart would be a better candidate given what we know of the activities among the Shar trainees. Or even Wyll, who could use some spice in his character.

In terms of representation, it's unfortunate that he doesn't become an option until Act 3.
Well, considering that Halsin is tied up with the main story of Act 2, I can understand that it would be not the right place and time to start the actual romance. However, a start point with more flirting could be added after saving Thaniel and Oliver and intimate scene remains in Act 3.
People say Shadowheart is not a good candidate if you take into account what we have in the game right now (that's why people dislike Halsin hitting on her and her sudden acceptance of it). If she was written differently from the very beginning, then maybe. I'd say Lae'zel fits better for such role, but it's just my opinion.

People keep saying that Astarion isn't a good fit because he's traumatized. Yet Shadowheart being tricked into torturing her own parents for like 30 years isn't traumatizing? Plus all the other stuff she's had to endure. Neither of them are a good fit I don't think.

I agree that Lae'zel would have made a better choice though because she definitely shows interest in being quite open early on. So it wouldn't come as a surprise to anyone if she were into poly or open relationships.