I don't think the games are even that far apart in terms of writing. For dialogue options I would say the writing quality are pretty much h the same, but wotr does indeed have more, so I think it wins there. In terms of companions, I don't think they're miles off either. I think wotr has some great companions with really compelling stories. I admit that the performances in BG3 are better though, and Karlach is still the best companion in either game. But the story of wotr I'd overall way better. In thag it actually makes sense when you lay it all out. Plus the story is always centered on us the player and our development. All those dialogue options also let us shape our character with a variety of personalities that BG3 doesn't pull off. Wotr isn't a masterpiece of writing, but it's pretty good.