I just accidentally
killed Minsc
twice because non-lethal damage was decidedly lethal. I had it toggled to on, checked and double-checked just to be sure. It was listed as a condition that would last until long rest. I've done this part of the playthrough before and did not have this problem.

Artist, Writer, Poet, Crank
Art, poetry, and prose of a grim and unserious nature.
https://www.lrjonte.com/