Originally Posted by Noelle666
Originally Posted by Netav
And who would you chose for that? As Shadowheart romancer I'm fully against adding in there too.
I'm not sure about Gale and Wyll, don't think it would be a good theme for them, but I've never romanced them, so maybe people with experience could tell us more.
I haven't romanced Gale, but I have romanced Wyll, so I'll comment briefly from that angle. Wyll thinks Halsin is a good and good-looking guy, and he wishes Halsin the best. However, Wyll's romance makes it extremely clear that he wants a monogamous relationship with the player character. If the PC tells him that Halsin has made overtures, Wyll will set boundaries in what I think is a very calm and mature manner. He says that he and the PC can still have a great story if the PC wants to be with Halsin; but that story won't be a romance. He's also firmly against anything with the drow twins. Honestly, what Wyll wanted was already so clear so that I felt kinda bad even just testing these things out and reloading. I already knew the sort of thing he would say, and my PC would never even open up the question naturally, if I hadn't been briefly out-of-character curious.

Really, I think the issue is that all the origin party members are written as not wanting to share the PC with each other. (I haven't played all the romances, so I am chiefly commenting here on the basis of material I have seen from other people; please do correct me if I'm wrong about anything.) When you consider that all of them can romance each other when the player is playing them, we can't just reduce this to a compatibility issue. They are honestly all compatible with each other (obviously depending on how the player chooses to RP the origin character). If they are not interested in romancing characters together that they would be happy romancing alone, the conclusion seems clear. They are all monogamous. How that's supposed to work with Halsin possibly being in the picture I genuinely don't know. People with more knowledge of Halsin's romance would be in a better picture to comment on that than I would.