Originally Posted by Zenith
A lot of DU is incoherent.

There is no way you can convince me your entire group except maybe Astarion and a Shar aligned Shadowheart won't leave you if you accept to be Bhaal's Chosen right in front of them. This is outright bonkers. You are saying in front of all of them that you're just going to be Orin 2.0, that you will use ghaik psionics to dominate and murder the world, and somehow Lazael, and the good aligned companions who would leave you if you kill the tieflings at the grove just STAY with you. That is just really incoherent writing.

Choosing to embrace Bhaal as his Chosen should cost you all companions but Astarion and Shar-aligned Shadowheart. Not even Minthara would support this decision, considering she was abducted and dominated by a Chosen of Bhaal, and she detests all gods for it.

Even at the very beginning it makes no sense. You are going to seriously tell me that you maim and eviscerate Alfira in a terrifying murder, and none of your camp mates take notice of the noises? Like what?

That's not entirely true, Minthara wouldn't leave you for replacing Orin, in Act 2 she will admit wanting to replace and rule as the new absolute and in Act 3 when playing Durge origin you can tell her you're a bhaalspawn, she says you need to claim your inheritance.

She literally worships power as well as wanting it for herself which is why she is easily cohersed to take the special tadpole with just simply offering it to her. I personally see Minthara as Viconia 2.0. Viconia also wanted the player to claim their inhertance in the classic BG2 ToB.

As for Shadowheart, I don't see her being entirely evil, she's kinda soft hearted and I don't see her being down with world domination under Bhaal or the Absolute either.

~Kensei~