I'm very much like you. I have only a small number of cRPGs that I like, and I'd much rather just replay those games than waste my valuable time on a (new) game that I know I won't like. Happy for you that BG3 falls into your liked-games box. Sad (given my love of the old BG games) that it does not for me.
Yeah, I'm sorry, this game isn't for you, but I 'm hopeful, that there might be some new RPGs in the future.
I'm always amazed, how people move so quickly from one game to another. A lot of people, I know, went from BG3 to Starfield to the new Cyberpunk DLC in two month. I'm still on my second BG3 playthrough ( did Tav first, now Durge).
I'm especially looking for games, that keep me occupied fora while. When there is nothing and I don't want to replay old games, then I play short story games like what remains of Edith Finch or The Shore, but I can't jump from blockbuster game to blockbuster game.
I do want to add, that I like discussing with you. We are often of different opinions, but you are always really chill, I really appreciate that.