Originally Posted by Zentu
Originally Posted by Netav
Well, she embraces Selune fully after House of grief fight, no?

Also fun fact
when you enter shadowlands for the first time - you get dialogue with Shadowheart how curse doesn't work on her and Shar loves her.
However, if you try to enter deep shadow zone(where you need pixie lantern/blessing bascially) - she still has no protection against it. Her "protection" basically mimics Isobel's blessing of Selune that allows you to walk around, but not in the deep shadows. Wouldn't Shar give her full protection from that, because it's her curse? Maybe it was Selune all along, that protected her.

That is an interesting point, could also be a game bug Larian needs to fix hehe

This does raise a question that makes no sense. She has been raised in Shar, her beliefs are in Shar. Shar would have no reason to "limit" her powers. By the Lore it would appear more likely this is a bug that Larian needs to fix in the game.
Also
Sceleritas Fel(Durge's butler) points that "two goddesses fight for her, but is she really that special?"(or something like that). So maybe they were fighting before too. Maybe Selune predicted/wanted Shadowheart to actually free Aylin(Still strange, because she "accepts" Shadowheart even if she killed the nightsong in act3, if she saves her parents on DJ path)