Praise:
Without spoilers. Or at least I'm only teasing the edges of spoiling the story. My favorite part was Shadowheart followed by Lae'zel.
Shadowheart's final choice did feel tragic. Whoever wrote that was a Forgotten Realms fan who really did understand the lore on Selune and Shar. The choice felt very Sharran.
I didn't expect to like Lae'zel as much as I did. But I'm a sucker for crisis of faith stories and I thought her story worked well.
The Cats. Love the cats.
Books. I loved the books. Some were clever and some were delightfully naughty. "Yoshimo is willing" indeed
Critique
Like Niara it's hard to say whether it deserved the award because you have omit so much to come a decision. Yes, if you disregard the end game, it's railroaded penultimate choice and the fact that you only have the illusion of choice in that instance. Yes, if you disregard the main plot, the fact that one of the major villains was a non entity, that the Wyll rewrite left Wyll with nothing to say . . . then? Then you have a really good game. But, ye gods, that's asking a great deal.
I couldn't vote because I had not opinions on the other games and it wouldn't allow me to vote for a voice actor and not make a decision about the game.
So the main story is a shambles but the rest is really good.
