So... would you say that you feel that a game winning an award when it's pitted against other games that do not even match the award category
Wait, I'm confused. Are you talking about Golden Joystic or the Game Awards? Because I absolutely agree with your post in context of Golden Joystick, but the Game Awards nominations make more sense. Every game with rich narration match this particular award category. Phantom Liberty has excellent narrative and from what I've heard Alan Wake 2 is very interesting too in terms of narration. Can't speak for Final Fantasy and Spider-Man.
