Originally Posted by JandK
Consumables I never seem to use, off the top of my head:

1. Holy water
2. Arsonist's oil
3. Oil of diminution
4. Wizardsbane oil
5. Remedial potion
Some of those, but not much. Overall, there are so many items, and UI/inventory gets so cluttered I end up selling more items that I use.

That is a general issue I am running in cRPG - I am generally terrible in using consumables because:
1) I am a hoarder
2) the games rarely are difficult enough to warrant an extra level of tedium. If smashing enemies in the head will work just fine, that fiddling with other tools just feels like waste of time and brain power.