Larian Banner: Baldur's Gate Patch 9
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 7 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Joined: Oct 2020
enthusiast
Offline
enthusiast
Joined: Oct 2020
Originally Posted by CosmicMayhem
Bumping this thread because we're still lacking proper act 3 Minthara, despite 3 major patches smile

I don't think that content ever existed. Minthara is like the other non-origin characters, her stuff is limited compared to theirs. There might be some dialogues that don't trigger but thats about it.

The Act 3 Minthara overhaul you are looking for wont be in until a year from now... maybe two. That is assuming Larian would even bother with such a project.
Which I really hope day will, I think Minthara should be available for a good playthrough and she along with ALL the other companions should have more scenes in Act 3.

Joined: Oct 2023
R
journeyman
Offline
journeyman
R
Joined: Oct 2023
Either way, keep being vocal about it. Minthara deserves Origin status. The damage is done btw, whether intentional or not. Also in the Meta way. The main cast VA's getting the spotlight but I haven't seen much from Minthara's and I haven't seen much from the Narrator as well... and I've been wondering who had voice 8 for thr custom character...

Joined: Mar 2020
veteran
Offline
veteran
Joined: Mar 2020
Where is new Minthara porn scenes


Larian's Biggest Oversight, what to do about it, and My personal review of BG3 EA
"74.85% of you stood with the Tieflings, and 25.15% of you sided with Minthara. Good outweighs evil, it seems."
Joined: Oct 2023
L
apprentice
Offline
apprentice
L
Joined: Oct 2023
Originally Posted by emery
Devs,

Honest question:

Why can't we Knock her out and find her later?

I understand Helsin and Minthara not wanting to stay in the same group, but players should have the option to spare even enemies, and than decides who stays.


This - exactly this.

Joined: Sep 2023
apprentice
Offline
apprentice
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Eddiar
Originally Posted by CosmicMayhem
Bumping this thread because we're still lacking proper act 3 Minthara, despite 3 major patches smile

I don't think that content ever existed. Minthara is like the other non-origin characters, her stuff is limited compared to theirs. There might be some dialogues that don't trigger but thats about it.

The Act 3 Minthara overhaul you are looking for wont be in until a year from now... maybe two. That is assuming Larian would even bother with such a project.
Which I really hope day will, I think Minthara should be available for a good playthrough and she along with ALL the other companions should have more scenes in Act 3.

It's definitely done. You can meet videos like this on youtube: . This video follows you to conclude what at some stage there was a way to recruit her in act 1
(probably like with Nere where after alliance with him you can persuade him about the lies of the cult)
. But for an unknown reason it was cut (in my opinion because they didn't have enough time before release). Hope that it will return in time.

Joined: Oct 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Oct 2023
This is a nice find! I somehow managed to get the same scene by rescuing her in Moonrise Towers, going back to Monastery, and then re-entering the Shadowlands. They probably planned a possible recruitment in Act 1, but never properly worked on it enough for it to be implemented. Same with Minsc frown

Anyway, I’m bumping the thread to ask: am I correct in thinking that Minthara is the only companion without a proper romance greeting or a kiss option?

I finally decided to romance her and there doesn’t seem to be any change to her voicelines. Is this the bug everyone was talking about? Or was the greeting/kiss never a feature at all? Kinda weird that I can kiss Halsin who is supposedly her “counterpart” and not her. Picking the option to “talk about something private” also leads to nothing and I’m not sure if this is a bug only on my end (due to 40+ mods) or it’s universal. Sorry if it’s been asked before, it’s a bit jarring to me.


Minthara bug list, updated for Hotfix #22.
Joined: Aug 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Aug 2023
Originally Posted by rendemption
This is a nice find! I somehow managed to get the same scene by rescuing her in Moonrise Towers, going back to Monastery, and then re-entering the Shadowlands. They probably planned a possible recruitment in Act 1, but never properly worked on it enough for it to be implemented. Same with Minsc frown

Anyway, I’m bumping the thread to ask: am I correct in thinking that Minthara is the only companion without a proper romance greeting or a kiss option?

I finally decided to romance her and there doesn’t seem to be any change to her voicelines. Is this the bug everyone was talking about? Or was the greeting/kiss never a feature at all? Kinda weird that I can kiss Halsin who is supposedly her “counterpart” and not her. Picking the option to “talk about something private” also leads to nothing and I’m not sure if this is a bug only on my end (due to 40+ mods) or it’s universal. Sorry if it’s been asked before, it’s a bit jarring to me.
Yeah they've been doing a lot of work just to get her romance flag functioning properly, interactions beyond that are either still in need of fixing or don't exist to begin with. There are a LOT of dialogues and reactivity with her that do exist in the files but much of it was intentionally cut and much of it just doesn't fire properly. Like the conversation to confirm the romance in Act 2 or 3 where she says you're hers that night is just an implication, the only scene that exists is the one you can pursue at the Goblin Party. Hotfix 9 also added a brand new bug where any time you gain Approval after reaching Very High approval, she bugs out and thinks you've cheated on her. It would be funny if her dialogue bugs hadn't already been omnipresent since launch.

The best that can be done currently is a debug mod to re-flag her romance after the bug happens but editing your save file that way obviously poses a little more risk than some mods.

Joined: Sep 2023
apprentice
Offline
apprentice
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by rendemption
Anyway, I’m bumping the thread to ask: am I correct in thinking that Minthara is the only companion without a proper romance greeting or a kiss option?

I finally decided to romance her and there doesn’t seem to be any change to her voicelines. Is this the bug everyone was talking about? Or was the greeting/kiss never a feature at all? Kinda weird that I can kiss Halsin who is supposedly her “counterpart” and not her. Picking the option to “talk about something private” also leads to nothing and I’m not sure if this is a bug only on my end (due to 40+ mods) or it’s universal. Sorry if it’s been asked before, it’s a bit jarring to me.

Well. Last hotfix actually fixed her romance (drow twins, final dialogue etc.) or its just worked for me (there was a bug when she thought I cheated but romance continued normally). There is now some different lines with her during others dialogues in act 3 (for example with dryad in circus) but nothing more. You can get kiss at final moments (end of game). Definitely some dialogues are still missing like "alurlssrin" (I missed it probably because of male drow tav but it would be strange if it is like that). That's all. Deffinetely lack of interaction during romance. So just be ready to "You wish to consult me?" most of the time. And hope for returning cut content.

Last edited by Bloodshed; 09/10/23 01:03 PM.
Joined: Oct 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Oct 2023
Originally Posted by Auric
Yeah they've been doing a lot of work just to get her romance flag functioning properly, interactions beyond that are either still in need of fixing or don't exist to begin with. There are a LOT of dialogues and reactivity with her that do exist in the files but much of it was intentionally cut and much of it just doesn't fire properly. Like the conversation to confirm the romance in Act 2 or 3 where she says you're hers that night is just an implication, the only scene that exists is the one you can pursue at the Goblin Party. Hotfix 9 also added a brand new bug where any time you gain Approval after reaching Very High approval, she bugs out and thinks you've cheated on her. It would be funny if her dialogue bugs hadn't already been omnipresent since launch.

The best that can be done currently is a debug mod to re-flag her romance after the bug happens but editing your save file that way obviously poses a little more risk than some mods.

Oh, there’s a whole new bug? Thank you for the heads up. Everything seems to be fine for me so far, but I ended up submitting a bug report to bring it to their attention. I suppose we don’t really have a way of knowing if the lack of options are due to a bug or it never existed at all - I strongly hope it’s the former because they seem to be focusing on fixing bugs more than anything else right now.

It’s really a shame that a lot of lines were cut, I just recently discovered most of them pertain to banter with other companions if Minthara is romanced. In terms of cut content, I would want those to be added first instead of the pregnancy plot they initially planned. Maybe it’s because I’m a woman but it’s just not that appealing to me, and there are other more interesting things that can be expanded upon like her connection to Lolth and being a Baenre (which is supposed to be a huge deal). On a lighter note, I find it funny how she's become my favorite companion even in her current buggy state.

Originally Posted by Bloodshed
Well. Last hotfix actually fixed her romance (drow twins, final dialogue etc.) or its just worked for me (there was a bug when she thought I cheated but romance continued normally). There is now some different lines with her during others dialogues in act 3 (for example with dryad in circus) but nothing more. You can get kiss at final moments (end of game). Definitely some dialogues are still missing like "alurlssrin" (I missed it probably because of male drow tav but it would be strange if it is like that). That's all. Deffinetely lack of interaction during romance. So just be ready to "You wish to consult me?" most of the time. And hope for returning cut content.

Okay, so I'll either to have to get used to her being my consultant for the remainder of Act 3 or I pause my run and wait until Larian fixes her sleep I hope that alurlssrin dialogue isn't locked away from drows too, that would be a bummer. Fingers crossed they change or add something to her in the next patch.


Minthara bug list, updated for Hotfix #22.
Joined: Nov 2023
T
stranger
Offline
stranger
T
Joined: Nov 2023
Bumping this thread to see if I should continue on.

So... this has been quite the interesting run when it comes to actually getting the intended outcome. As many have stated, I too have done all I can to get the proper romance and story beats associated with furthering a relationship with Minthara. I didn't flirt with anyone and the only thing I can think I've done is give a Black Oleander to Shadowheart in Act 2 but that never caused any issues with my Lae'Zel romance on my 2nd playthrough. I got the proper Act 1 and 2 scenes with her and have said everything you should to achieve the romance. I get to Act 3 after the meeting with the Emperor and she says we are together, forever bound and she would have me that night. No cutscene of course but I figured all seemed fine otherwise. Then we get to Rivington and after talking to her she mentions pickpockets (strange since no one attempted to pick pocketed her) and after that line of dialog I exit the conversation and once again speak to her. She immediately stated I seeked affection from someone else even though I have not been remotely romantic to anyone else this run except her.

Then we go to the dryad in the circus and after getting all the questions right (Minthara's approval is near max at this point) the dryad states that my character's heart belonged to another and mine and Minthara's love was fragile. This has very much confused me and I'm unsure why I would be getting such a response when I've been nothing but devoted to her romance this run. I go to the Drow twins in Sharesses Caress and surprisingly she states she doesn't want to share me with them and states we are together. I'm confused and aggravated at the possibility that continuing on may not yield anything more worthwhile when it comes to her personal story and romance with my character.

What am I supposed to do? After hearing her response with the Drow twins I'm a bit relieved but unsure if it's still bugged or not. Very frustrating to say the least.

Should I keep going?

Last edited by Thrag; 15/11/23 09:43 AM.
Joined: Oct 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Oct 2023
Originally Posted by Thrag
She immediately stated I seeked affection from someone else even though I have not been remotely romantic to anyone else this run except her.
Hello! There is currently an approval bug with Minthara where she will accuse of you cheating when you reach 70+ approval points. This is likely what happened after that pickpocket dialogue. Larian hasn't fixed it yet and this bug doesn't seem to happen for everyone. Around a week ago, I found a Reddit thread highlighting the same issue. Maybe it can help you. I strongly advise you to submit a bug report to Larian anyway to help them out, and be sure to attach your save file if it is unmodded.

As for continuing or not, it's up to you. There isn't much content for Minthara to begin with in terms of romance, so you won't lose out on much. If you don't want to wait for a fix, I'd suggest using Script Extender to re-set her flags.


Minthara bug list, updated for Hotfix #22.
Joined: Nov 2023
T
stranger
Offline
stranger
T
Joined: Nov 2023
Thanks for the response. I'm just going to forge ahead and hope maybe I can squeeze some new story content out of the experience with her. I'm already doing an evil run so I'm getting some new stuff as is. Was just hoping to get more out of it romancing and having her in the party since I didn't even know she could be apart of the group until my second run 400 odd hours in.

Joined: Jul 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Jul 2023
I still have one character save that I prepared for Minthara that still sits on the nautiloid until Larian properly fixes Minthy because I still keep reading and hearing that she's still unfinished somehow, doesn't have proper romance scenes. So, yeah... and I really really can't wait to experience her.

Joined: Nov 2023
stranger
Offline
stranger
Joined: Nov 2023
Same. I’m in the middle of Act 2 with Minthara, but it feels like I should also wait until she’s fixed. Argh, it’s frustrating.

Joined: Nov 2023
S
stranger
Offline
stranger
S
Joined: Nov 2023
iirc wait until the end of Act 2. That's when her dialogue and stuff really starts to pick up. It will always feels like less than the other companions simply because it is.

Joined: Oct 2023
stranger
Offline
stranger
Joined: Oct 2023
Hello I've come here today to tell you: Minthara is amazing and needs more content and her bugs fixed, it's been freaking 3 months, Larian what are you doing-

Joined: Oct 2020
old hand
Offline
old hand
Joined: Oct 2020
I'm over halfway act 3, but it still goes:

Tav : I want to talk about a private matter
Min : Then speak
Tav : Actually, never mind.

No other choices. I'm not romancing anyone else, murdered the grove for her, and attempt to make most decisions so that she will aprove. (Which was not always successful, but still I would love some more interactions, even if she doesn't want romance)

Joined: Oct 2023
member
Offline
member
Joined: Oct 2023
I genuinely think Minthara fans need to be more annoying online if we want them to fix her and fill in the gaps, like missing dialogue options and such.


Minthara bug list, updated for Hotfix #22.
Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
I recruited her recently and now I completely get what all the fuss is about, she's great.

Joined: Dec 2020
veteran
Offline
veteran
Joined: Dec 2020
I just reloaded a save with my gith mage before I killed Minthara and knocked her out. She probably will hate my guts , when she becomes a companion, because I'm goody good, but I guess, she will be more entertaining than Halsin. Her comments with clown were gold already ( saw that on YouTube and loved it).


"We are all stories in the end. Just make it a good one."

Doctor Who
Page 7 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5