I'm sure it's been addressed already, but the writer did a horrendous job of applying forethought into the matter. In case it hasn't been brought up, several factors inevitably lead up to a nasty surprise at the brothel.


Shadowheart says she is alright with an orgy at the brothel and has been fantasizing about Halsin, while you have been in a relationship. The argument that you can avoid this scenario by not going to see the drow twins in the first place is idiotic because every GOOD roleplaying gamer is going to explore every feasible possibility and see if there are any other rewards available from them besides sex. Shadowheart is of course going to be in my party because I never remove my romantic partner. And as far as Halsin is concerned, his character was introduced late, so he was in the party because I was trying develop his approval.

This lead to a situation where I ended up seeing a dialog that I am unable to UN-see. Now Shadowheart will always be guilty of fantasizing about Halsin while being in a relationship with me, regarldless of whether or not I reload to a save prior to entering the brothel.

I almost rage quit this game, and that would have been a shame because it does justice to Bioware's releases in every which way and is a phenomenal game in its own right as well. To your writer's credit, I discovered after breaking up with Shadowheart that she laments my loss and says she will likely never find another person like me again. This was just enough to get me to forgive her and go back to playing, after I gratuitously killed the bisexual bear mascot a few dozen times.

I've tolerated
the male characters incessantly hitting on my male PC one after another. I've tolerated Halsin's constant ogling. I've tolerated the hot chick you made me create as my "protector" at the start of the game turning out to be male and going through its "transition" into the Emperor, after I gave him a hug.
This is the world we live in, and we have to learn to tolerate and laugh. But in the case of this particular dialog, your writer has crossed the threshold of depravity. Whether homosexual or heterosexual, partners expect fidelity from one another. If you will not rectify the matter because the final version has been released, make the toolset available and I'm sure modders will be delighted correct the issue for you.