Originally Posted by Gottfried
Originally Posted by Netav
She says that very early and it explained why she "prefers" that(because Shar forbids shit, she has no choice). She is not liek that in her selune path, everything about her selune path romance suggests love and commitment. I guess DJ Shadowheart breaks up with you ne matter what on Shar's demand. It's is reflected in her epilogue pretty well.

"What can change the nature of a woman?"

See, this is one of the parts where that whole Shar subplot starts loosing me, and it never gets addressed. It's very much a failing of "Bioware writing", and seemingly also of what Larian does (or strives to imitate). Intriguing concepts don't exist to be explored, but just as a curiosity in a story that does not truly care. Shar is evil, Shadowheart was brainwashed, let's move on. Nature vs. nurture ... you want to talk about this game? Nope, Shadowheart was brainwashed, let's move on. Okay, but is she still into whipping me? Game? Game? She killed and tortured people!

The point of this slight tirade being: Who is Shadowheart really? She is very kinky throughout most of the game. Are we to believe that this was the result of Shar's brainwashing as well? Should we just arbitrarily group all her pre-revelation traits into the "Shar" and "Selunite" baskets, depending on what we consider "good" or "bad". Did her whole personality suddenly change? How does that even work?
Being kinky is 1 thing, I don't mind her being kinky at all. I have no problem with Sharess caress encounter at all, because she is down for it if you are only and she is fine with that. Things get weird only when Halsin around and specifically this disapproval message.

As for shar brainwashing/selune thing. It is established that Shar forbids any romantical relationship and any of those connections are bound to be terminated on Shar's demand(She straight up says you that and breaks up with you in the end if she is dark justiciar). It's not about her being kinky or w/e, it's about how things are when you are sharran, reffering to her "short amusments" banter thing early in act 1. You just can't say she prefers "short amusments" after you get her epilogue selune ending(she calls you "true love" in the game too, but only on her selune path).