I couldn't disagree more. To me, Wyll is one of the strongest and most upstanding characters in the game, and incredibly worth of respect.
Not going to argue with you as I do know the pain of liking a companion (romance-able one) that others "don't get". When you see the depths and nuances in every word, gesture and face expression, while others are indifferent to all of these at best. This is my turn to "don't get". My deepest apologies if I caused you pain over it.
I don't think, he needs a rewrite, he needs more content. People will always go for the flashy characters and not the morally good. Maybe give some examples of what you would like Wyll to do. 'Re-write everything' is not helpful. That is, what I would write for Halsin (better write him out), but that is not really helping. I'm not vibing with Halsin, so I have no idea, what to do with him, maybe it is the same with you and Wyll?
No, not helpful at all, absolutely agree. Probably you are right and it is the same thing as with you and Halsin. (Funny thing: I misread your answer first and wanted to enthusiastically agree, that yes, let's give a lot of Wyll's lines to Halsin, it will be perfect!) Or maybe I had too high expectations (I imagined the paladin from DnD movie, yet Wyll proved to be nothing like that character). And though I do have ideas about how he could be made better, the changes are too dramatic, practically a re-write anyway. As he is now, a bit more agency and a little less lore-absurdity would help but I doubt we will see either.
