Larian Banner: Baldur's Gate Patch 9
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 18 of 24 1 2 16 17 18 19 20 23 24
Joined: Nov 2023
A
stranger
Offline
stranger
A
Joined: Nov 2023
That's super confusing... do you have a video of it or a screenshot?

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by adriana
That's super confusing... do you have a video of it or a screenshot?

Sorry, no. And I don't want to go through the whole ending again to get a screenshot. It's the morning after the ending on the docks and it's like the game can't tell which version of Astarion I have.

Joined: Sep 2023
V
member
Offline
member
V
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Originally Posted by adriana
That's super confusing... do you have a video of it or a screenshot?

Sorry, no. And I don't want to go through the whole ending again to get a screenshot. It's the morning after the ending on the docks and it's like the game can't tell which version of Astarion I have.

This is is a Dark Urge specific line no matter the LI. I guess it simply means that even if you rejected Bhaal you are still a Bhaalspawn and are for example not free to sire children/get pregnant because they'd become Bhaalspawn, too.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Veranis
This is is a Dark Urge specific line no matter the LI. I guess it simply means that even if you rejected Bhaal you are still a Bhaalspawn and are for example not free to sire children/get pregnant because they'd become Bhaalspawn, too.

Mmm. Could have sworn I didn't have it with spawn Astarion before, but my memory is as good as Durge's.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Baldur's Gate 3 Developers Explain ...racters, and Making the Best RPG of 2023

"So we knew it wasn't that complete, it was very abrupt, but we wanted to finish and so now it's better."

At least they admit it's bad.

Joined: Aug 2023
journeyman
Offline
journeyman
Joined: Aug 2023
Originally Posted by Anska
And it's not, as if less cruel versions of these comments didn't exist. Adding an option to follow Astarion sounds like an endeavour but using the character reactions from his Origin for the Companion version as well, sounds much less challenging.

That would at least be an improvement.

Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Larian added a little scene to the end of the drow orgy of all things. They sure can add a short animation of the pc walking towards Astarion's general direction after Karlach is dealt with, for those who choose to do so. He's right there behind some crates.

Well, they have their priorities sorted out. I guess, lol.

Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
And change what the narrator says if Astarion is the only person with us on the docks. Neither me nor any of my characters would ever think "the guy who's been abused for years will be fine by himself because he's good at comforting himself, I don't need to go check up on him."

Haven't had an epilogue with just Astarion and my Char yet. It sounds ridiculous. Each of my characters and I would certainly feel the need to make sure he's safe and accompany him.

Originally Posted by ahania
Originally Posted by Alithea
Why is his huge character-defining moment turned into a tasteless joke?

I didn't answer because I assumed that it was obvious I agree that it is not handled the best. Maybe the biggest difference between our views is that I do not see it as a huge character-defining moment for Astarion the same way the dock scene is a huge moment for Lae'zel, Karlach, or Gale.

While there are comments about the sun throughout the game by act two I thought his arc was more about trauma and bodily autonomy. After his quest is completed he would be able to start the healing process and start being able to process emotions and situations in a more balanced and healthy way. Of course, he's just a fictional guy and it is all just speculation, but for me, he was already after his big moment.

When I romanced him, I played as the Dark Urge and my Tav assumed he could protect himself, the same way he took care of my character during the game. In romanced and non-romanced games too I imagined the group going after him, but I never felt I needed an extra cutscene.

It's only mildly related, but even after several playthroughs I feel like the group dynamics need more work. The companions never came across as friends (at most they seemed to be coworkers). The remarks at the docks scene seemed to underline my assumptions that they do not like each other, and they really don't like Astarion. I would love it if Larian could put more work into this.

While Astarion's "big moment" is with Cazador, the sun is brought up during the whole game, not only in dialogue. You get the scene of him basking in the morning sun, he talks about the colors he sees for the first time in centuries. The moment on the docks shows the consequences for his decision to not ascend. It could have been an incredible moment that shows the extent of his sacrifice. Instead it turned out extremely tasteless.

I believe his arc is about trauma, bodily autonomy and so much more than that. It's about freedom and healing and trust to name a few.
Even if he can protect himself (and in hindsight we know that he can), that's not the point. As I told you before, the point is, my Character is forced to act as if she doesn't care about Astarion. Despite the promise she made.
They added a cut scene for the sharess caress orgy, they surely can at least add my character running after Astarion. If they'd switch his and Karlach's moments, he could even go to Avernus if the player feels like it.

It would be nice if the companions were friendlier to each other and were more lively in act 3 in general.

Joined: Nov 2023
A
old hand
Offline
old hand
A
Joined: Nov 2023
Originally Posted by Alithea
It would be nice if the companions were friendlier to each other and were more lively in act 3 in general.

This above all. In general I am starting to get a Karlach problem that gets worse every play-through, the amount of effort the game puts into making you and all the companions like her, is disproportional to the attention the other characters get, especially those who share similar problems to her's. I mean look at the drama her exploding gets compared to the way Gale goes out, if you choose to blow him up. Besides the whole Astarion burning in the sun issue.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Anska
Originally Posted by Alithea
It would be nice if the companions were friendlier to each other and were more lively in act 3 in general.

This above all. In general I am starting to get a Karlach problem that gets worse every play-through, the amount of effort the game puts into making you and all the companions like her, is disproportional to the attention the other characters get, especially those who share similar problems to her's. I mean look at the drama her exploding gets compared to the way Gale goes out, if you choose to blow him up. Besides the whole Astarion burning in the sun issue.

Yep, she gets special treatment. If it works it works, but if it doesn't it can be really annoying. As a result she's never in my camp.

Joined: Nov 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Nov 2023
Originally Posted by Anska
This above all. In general I am starting to get a Karlach problem that gets worse every play-through, the amount of effort the game puts into making you and all the companions like her, is disproportional to the attention the other characters get, especially those who share similar problems to her's. I mean look at the drama her exploding gets compared to the way Gale goes out, if you choose to blow him up. Besides the whole Astarion burning in the sun issue.

The more the game blatantly attempts to make me care for her, while not giving the same attention to other characters who also have these problems, the more I get put off by her character.

Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Yep, she gets special treatment. If it works it works, but if it doesn't it can be really annoying. As a result she's never in my camp.

I would do the same in my future second playthrough with my Tav, were she not the perfect candidate for the heroic sacrifice, because she became expendable to me after taking Gortash's deal and her story makes her look like a cannon fodder character in the first place. Funnily enough, I cared more about the guy who I could finally chat with for the very first time (through Lae'zel's story) than someone who had been with me since act 1. Even that epilogue tries to make her as likeable as possible. rolleyes

Joined: Aug 2023
journeyman
Offline
journeyman
Joined: Aug 2023
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Originally Posted by Anska
Originally Posted by Alithea
It would be nice if the companions were friendlier to each other and were more lively in act 3 in general.

This above all. In general I am starting to get a Karlach problem that gets worse every play-through, the amount of effort the game puts into making you and all the companions like her, is disproportional to the attention the other characters get, especially those who share similar problems to her's. I mean look at the drama her exploding gets compared to the way Gale goes out, if you choose to blow him up. Besides the whole Astarion burning in the sun issue.

Yep, she gets special treatment. If it works it works, but if it doesn't it can be really annoying. As a result she's never in my camp.

Same. Not going through that again therefore not going to recruit her anymore. It's a shame because I really liked Karlach.

Joined: Sep 2023
Location: Wales
B
member
Offline
member
B
Joined: Sep 2023
Location: Wales
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Larian added a little scene to the end of the drow orgy of all things. They sure can add a short animation of the pc walking towards Astarion's general direction after Karlach is dealt with, for those who choose to do so. He's right there behind some crates.

And change what the narrator says if Astarion is the only person with us on the docks. Neither me nor any of my characters would ever think "the guy who's been abused for years will be fine by himself because he's good at comforting himself, I don't need to go check up on him."

Quoted to keep this thread active and noticeable They need to swop the Karlach dock scene and the Astarion dock scene in the running order. A while back there was a poster (not sure if it was this thread or another) who played as Astarion and romanced Karlach, that must have been the most disappointing ending imaginable. You run away from your lover cos you're burning she starts to burn up as well and either dies or goes to Avernus (possibly with someone else) while you are forced to lurk behind some crates and can't comfort your love interest or go with her because you are out of dialogue range. Did larian really think that would never happen or something?
If they did that, following Astarion off the docks (if he didn't go to Avernus) would be the most natural thing in the world

Last edited by Bethra; 18/12/23 05:43 PM.

# Justice for Astarion
Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Bethra
Quoted to keep this thread active and noticeable They need to swop the Karlach dock scene and the Astarion dock scene in the running order. A while back there was a poster (not sure if it was this thread or another) who played as Astarion and romanced Karlach, that must have been the most disappointing ending imaginable. You run away from lover cos you burning she starts to burn up as well and either dies or goes to Avernus (possibly with someone else) while you are forced to lurk behind some crates and can't comfort your love interest. Did larian really think that would never happen or something?

Meanwhile if you play as Karlach you get Astarion's whole romance adapted to her situation. Don't know about the ending though, it probably still sucks.

Well, in that article they did admit that they just couldn't be bothered to figure it out.

Joined: Nov 2023
A
old hand
Offline
old hand
A
Joined: Nov 2023
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Meanwhile if you play as Karlach you get Astarion's whole romance adapted to her situation. Don't know about the ending though, it probably still sucks.

Again, not so much for other people with poisonous blood. But I'll take those extra approval points, for letting him nibble, thank you very much.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Anska
Originally Posted by t1mekill3r
Meanwhile if you play as Karlach you get Astarion's whole romance adapted to her situation. Don't know about the ending though, it probably still sucks.

Again, not so much for other people with poisonous blood. But I'll take those extra approval points, for letting him nibble, thank you very much.

Well, it should be different for Gale too, especially since he's been in development longer.

Another thing that was disappointing in Astarion's origin was that the game never acknowledges how well he understands what Minthara's been through with the worm, and her need for revenge.

Joined: Nov 2023
A
old hand
Offline
old hand
A
Joined: Nov 2023
I haven't had the pleasure with Minthara yet, but I was in general surprised how few reminders of his past with Cazador he gets. In Gale's Origin, whenever something pops up that Mystra might have an opinion on, the narration reminds you about it or prompts you to consider your own position on the matter - usually this also coincides with one of Astarion's little manipulation attempts. It is a good representation of how important Mystra still is to him and creates a nice (percieved) dynamic between the characters.

Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Astarion's past before Cazador was cut and they didn't give him a new one. Cazador related stuff changed too. That might be why there's nothing in his origin and why the narrator says things that don't make sense sometimes, like "your master's coven is close to Baldur's Gate" when the palace is in the middle of the city, or how sunlight on his skin feels like "a caress of a lover who doesn't know better yet". 5 patches and they haven't figured out that maybe they shouldn't imply that he enjoyed being used that way.

Joined: Sep 2023
Location: Wales
B
member
Offline
member
B
Joined: Sep 2023
Location: Wales
Makes no sense whatsoever. A huge chunk of Act2 and the Act 3 (up to when you go to the palace) is him being celibate (and so are we of course) to get over his trauma.
They wrote that, then ignored it on multiple occasions.
It's not only Spawn Astarion, Ascended Asatarion has some diabolical voice lines for Tav that show at least one of the writers hadn't done any homework.

You're really left doing the thing I was hoping I wouldn't have to do with Larian - which is wait for modders to fix it (when did Bethesda take over?).

One modder has thankfully dealt with the worst of Ascended Astarion and Tavs dialogue (oddly it isn't what he says that's the issue its what Tav says - so no idea what Larian was thinking by that point).

But that damn dock scene is the absolute pits and should be cut out of the scene altogether and consigned to an incinerator.


# Justice for Astarion
Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Originally Posted by Bethra
Makes no sense whatsoever. A huge chunk of Act2 and the Act 3 (up to when you go to the palace) is him being celibate (and so are we of course) to get over his trauma.
They wrote that, then ignored it on multiple occasions.
It's not only Spawn Astarion, Ascended Asatarion has some diabolical voice lines for Tav that show at least one of the writers hadn't done any homework.

You're really left doing the thing I was hoping I wouldn't have to do with Larian - which is wait for modders to fix it (when did Bethesda take over?).

One modder has thankfully dealt with the worst of Ascended Astarion and Tavs dialogue (oddly it isn't what he says that's the issue its what Tav says - so no idea what Larian was thinking by that point).

But that damn dock scene is the absolute pits and should be cut out of the scene altogether and consigned to an incinerator.

Which lines? And what mod? Got me curious.

Joined: Sep 2023
Location: Wales
B
member
Offline
member
B
Joined: Sep 2023
Location: Wales
https://www.nexusmods.com/baldursgate3/mods/5037?

Encountered soon after Ascension. Basically 'Make me a vampire too', 'Have sex with me', or scolding him like a teenager (Hope you've learned something from all this).

Sooo the entire thing was cos I wanted my Tav to be a vampire, or I view Astarion as a sex object, or he's a kid in need of admonishment.

Very poorly written , and none of the options have a hint of affection.

Modder just softened the edges a bit

Last edited by Bethra; 19/12/23 06:37 PM.

# Justice for Astarion
Joined: Sep 2023
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Sep 2023
Ah, that one. When the writing is so bad you need a mod to make it make sense.

Tho to be fair the player's dialogue in the graveyard scene isn't masterclass of writing either.

If I could mod I'd mess around with his Act 2 convos a bit. Araj was a good idea, but the implementation sucks in the romance version.

Last edited by t1mekill3r; 19/12/23 07:14 PM.
Page 18 of 24 1 2 16 17 18 19 20 23 24

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5