Originally Posted by saeran
But from the discord discussions I've noticed some male players view her as some sort of sheltered cloister girl fantasy, which I think is out of character for a Sharran. And I also remember, her early EA version was a bit different, but male players complained and the writing was changed.

I wonder if the whole issue would even be an issue for some if the number three wasn't a huge, brawny elf but ... say Alfira?

Shart's romance - or at least the early stages of it - felt very weird to me anyway. If you do not kiss her during the night the two of you spent talking, she disapproves, as if the PC was someone cast in a role of her personal phantasy. If you do kiss her, she instantly gets (or got in my version) a line about how she wanted to become a Dark Justiciar but now she might not have to anymore ... we haven't known each other for a tenday, darling? But I guess some really like this weird clinginess, and I can imagine that the whole Act3 brothel/Halsin thing might feel especially strange then. That said, the whole brothel encounter is best left avoided anyway.