Originally Posted by Ehhhh123
I don't think most people truly give a damn about Halsin, as in they'll never take him in their party. I mean, where's the incentive to do so? That's why a lot of people don't notice all the exceptionally questionable crap about him. Maybe if the stars align, more people think: "Why not"? and include Halsin in their party while at the same time romancing Shadowheart, then maybe we'd see way more complaints. But as I said, there's truly no reason to bring him into your party so that's probably not going to happen for a good while.
Or maybe everyone's experience and perception is different. I've had Halsin in my party the first playthrough, admittedly not that often because I don't like shapeshifting in combat. Never got the brothel dialogue, I guess because I didn't propose them. But after the creepy dialogues I've got from Astarion and Gale, by the time Halsin made his advances I didn't care.